NOTE: This is a 2022 listing. All information listed pertains to 2022 only and does not apply to 2023.

CAPS Paranormal Investigations

Visit Website Add to My Favorites

Historic Gainor's Tavern

Do you want to do a real paranormal investigation of a well documented haunted location?

Here’s your chance, join our team as we continue the investigations of the Gainor Tavern.

Originally built in 1877, the building was served as a general store, black smith shop, tavern, post office, dance hall, and bar. The building was built by Michael Gainor, and was sold to Phillip Barry when Michael retired to Appleton to manager his other rental properties, however when a fire destroyed the building Michael sold 5 of his properties in Appleton to move back to Mackville and restore the building he built.

When Michael retired for good, he sold the property to his son Joe Gainor and his wife Katherine. Who in turn sold the property years later to Katherine’s nephew, Floyd Reiland and his wife Frances “Babe” Reiland.

After they both passed away, the property was set up as a trust to their children who managed it as a rental property for years until a fatal fire burned the living quarters in 1987 and that part of the building was tore down.

In 1993, the building was sold for the first time outside of the family to the current owners and has remained in their possession till this day.

Although there are many stories associated with the building, only a few are actually true and have documentation.

Some of the most notable claims that we have documented proof of:
- a male disembodied voice
- a female disembodied voice
- objects moving on their own
- doors opening and closing on their own
- lights turning on and off on their own
- knocking in response to questions
- the sound of someone sitting down next to you on furniture
- physical interactions including being touched, hair brushed, and scratched.

and other unexplained responses through our equipment (REM Pod, EMF Meter, Ovilus)

Bring your own equipment or we have some you can use while here!
Audio and Video recording is encouraged, here is your chance to investigate with the paranormal.

For the very first timers, to the experienced professionals, we can walk you though, or you can take the lead! The time is yours!


Limited space is available for the tours so make sure you purchase your tickets in advance.

NOTE: This is a 2022 listing. All information listed pertains to 2022 only and does not apply to 2023.

2022 Dates & Times

April 24; May 22; June 12; August 21; September 18; October 2, 9, 16, 23, 30

6pm till 10pm
If doing additional Basement tour add an extra hour at end

Cost & Discounts

$40 per person


Buy Tickets Now


Beansnappers/Gainor Tavern
N2901 WI-47
Appleton, WI 54913

Outagamie County

Google Maps directions


  • Free Parking
  • Gift Shop

How to Find Us


Google Maps directions

Event map

Listing Managed By


Last Updated

Oct. 3, 2022, 2:15 p.m.

May 29th, 2023 10:29 p.m. CDT 16.2